Nexus One 3G Problems?

Well, it’s been five days since Google began taking orders for the Nexus One, and in those five days, many people have had a chance to test out the N1 on T-Mobile’s service.  Unfortunately, it appears that many people are having issues with their 3G coverage with the N1.  Now, sometimes it’s hard to determine the exact extent of a problem based off internet support forums, but considering it’s been about five days, well four for most since it takes a day for delivery, it could be a big problem.Many people have been reporting that their N1 will not maintain a 3G connection and often switch to EDGE even when other phones, sitting right next to their N1 on T-Mobile’s network are pulling in 3G just fine.  There is an article on Gizmodo with a user posting a nice image of their G1 next to their N1 and while the G1 is on 3G the N1 is reporting EDGE.

N1 and G1 Reception

There are some 141 comments on that article with some users reporting the same problems and others reporting no problems at all.  Could this be a hardware issue or a firmware issue?  Hopefully is this is a real problem it can up fixed with a timely update.

Meanwhile on Engadget there is another article stating Google’s support forums are getting bloated with complaint about 3G service with the N1.  There is a quote taken from an interview today with All Things D:

In an interview today at All Things D here at CES, Walt Mossberg mentioned the support problems to which Andy Rubin replied “we have to get better at customer service”…

I’d say so.  I’m not sure Google has the customer service part of this figured out.  Sure, hardware questions should be directed toward HTC and service questions directed to T-Mobile.  However, I think having different entities support different aspects of a phone can lead to too much frustration, as I could see one company blaming the other and vice verse.  In an article from nexus404.com a user has had some issues with both HTC and T-Mobile’s support:

Interestingly one user who has contacted HTC directly was helpfully told to direct questions to T-Mobile – which would indicate, it would seem, that HTC suspect that the issue may lay with T-Mobiles 3G network, but many remain unconvinced that this is indeed the case. That said, at least one user has reported that HTC have agreed to replace their specific handset (so who knows where the fault truly lies?).

“I upgraded from a Blackberry Pearl to the Nexus One. I cannot get any 3G service as of yet,” writes one poster. “Don’t know what the problem is. T-mobile and HTC support weren’t able to help.”

Let’s hope that this gets worked out soon, if it is software and can be fixed.  If it’s hardware, I think I’ll wait a few more months to see what’s coming down the pipes.

, ,

  • me

    I have the same problem in several locations with a BlackBerry 9700, Nokia N900, and mytouch 3G. They flicker in and out of 3G/EDGE/GPRS when the area is a strong 3G area (according to the engineers). I think it is a problem of T-mobile and not so much the device. They probably just have the power on the towers too low.

  • me

    I have the same problem in several locations with a BlackBerry 9700, Nokia N900, and mytouch 3G. They flicker in and out of 3G/EDGE/GPRS when the area is a strong 3G area (according to the engineers). I think it is a problem of T-mobile and not so much the device. They probably just have the power on the towers too low.

  • http://nexuscellphone.com Scott P

    5 days isn’t that long really to find bugs. Though one would think Google would have found these issues during the Dog Food beta testing process.

  • http://nexuscellphone.com Scott P

    5 days isn’t that long really to find bugs. Though one would think Google would have found these issues during the Dog Food beta testing process.

  • http://droidstory.com droidstory

    I’m having the same problem and noticed that the 3G connection drops as soon as you hold the phone in your hand. http://droidstory.com/2010/01/10/nexus-one-3g-problems/

  • http://droidstory.com droidstory

    I’m having the same problem and noticed that the 3G connection drops as soon as you hold the phone in your hand. http://droidstory.com/2010/01/10/nexus-one-3g-problems/

  • Ian B

    Talked to HTC today and they said that an over the network update will be forthcoming very soon that should fix the problem.

  • Ian B

    Talked to HTC today and they said that an over the network update will be forthcoming very soon that should fix the problem.

  • http://www.i208.net Rob Khonsu

    For anyone who has a rooted phone, this has happened from time to time with JF and CN distributions of Android. It’s normally patched within a week; however because both JF and CN are one man development teams there is no QA to go through.

    First with this being a T-Mobile HTC handset I wonder how easy it is to root, and second I wonder if you load CN4.2.12 if the 3G problem will still exist.

  • http://www.i208.net Rob Khonsu

    For anyone who has a rooted phone, this has happened from time to time with JF and CN distributions of Android. It’s normally patched within a week; however because both JF and CN are one man development teams there is no QA to go through.

    First with this being a T-Mobile HTC handset I wonder how easy it is to root, and second I wonder if you load CN4.2.12 if the 3G problem will still exist.

  • ButcherChop

    Looks like the issue has been resolved for me. I feel bad cuz i gave HTC support hell today and was returning my phone. Now I love it again. I wasnt dropped to EDGE all day today while driving around. Stayed on 3G all through the West Valley.
    My bars also dont drop like before. It was horrible seeing my sister’s G1 have 1-2 more bars than my Nexus.

  • ButcherChop

    Looks like the issue has been resolved for me. I feel bad cuz i gave HTC support hell today and was returning my phone. Now I love it again. I wasnt dropped to EDGE all day today while driving around. Stayed on 3G all through the West Valley.
    My bars also dont drop like before. It was horrible seeing my sister’s G1 have 1-2 more bars than my Nexus.

  • Michael Magliotti

    So that means it could be HTC’s fault. This is the first time I hear any kind of OTA mention from HTC, Google, and TMobile.

  • Michael Magliotti

    So that means it could be HTC’s fault. This is the first time I hear any kind of OTA mention from HTC, Google, and TMobile.